| Starting Character | Player |
| --- | --- |
| Nightwatchman | Lyn |
| Scarlet Woman | Kira |
| Choirboy | Wesley |
| Godfather | Griffin |
| Butler | Maddox |
| Goon | Art |
| Chambermaid | Andy |
| Kazali | Nelson |
| Slayer | Paul |
| Saint | Brian |
| Undertaker | Alex |
Night 1:
- Nelson picks Griffin as evil Godfather (drew Politician), Kira as Scarlet Woman (drew Empath)
- Nelson sees Mayor/Innkeeper/Balloonist
- Maddox picks Art, Art drunks Maddox
- Lyn picks Andy, Andy sees Lyn as Nightwatchman
- Andy picks Nelson/Paul: 1
- Nelson kills Wesley (9 players left)
- Wesley learns Brian
- Griffin also kills Wesley
- Alex undertakes Butler
- Andy picks Nelson Kira: 0 (mistake, should be 1)
Day 2:
- Griffin -> Andy: 0
- Andy -> Griffin: 5
- Alex -> Lyn: 6 (Ghost: Maddox)
- Lyn executed, dies (8 players left)
Night 3:
- Nelson picks Art, Art drunks Nelson, Art becomes evil
- Alex undertakes nightwatchman
- Andy picks Nelson/Kira: 1
Day 3:
- Andy -> Griffin: 5
- Alex -> Kira: 1
- Nelson -> Alex: 4
- Griffin executed, dies (7 players left)
Night 4:
- Nelson kills Alex (6 players left)
- Andy picks Nelson/Kira: 1
Day 4:
- Kira -> Brian: 1
- Andy -> Kira: 3
- Art -> Andy: 1
- Paul slays Andy: no
- Nelson -> Paul: 3
- Paul -> Art: 5
- Art executed, dies (5 players left)
Night 5:
- I tell Andy I messed up his night 2 and correct it
- Nelson kills Brian (4 players left)
- Andy picks Paul/Kira: 0
Day 5:
- I announce a mistake has been made and corrected
- Andy -> Nelson: 2, Kira voted to look opposed to Nelson
- Kira -> Andy: 3 (Ghost: Brian)
- Paul -> Lyn: 3 (Ghost: Art) This is rough in hindsight
- No execution
Night 6:
- Nelson kills Paul (3 players left)
- Andy picks Nelson/Kira: 1
Day 6:
- Andy -> Nelson: 4 (Ghost: Alex/Wesley/Paul)
- Nelson -> Kira: 1
- Kira -> Andy: 2
- Nelson executed, dies (2 players left, no demon)
| Starting Character | Player |
| --- | --- |
| Widow | Nelson |
| Sage | Lyn |
| Lunatic (Fang Gu) | Megan |
| Marionette (Undertaker) | Frankie |
| Fang Gu | Serene |
| Nightwatchman | Brian |
| Empath | Griffin |
| Innkeeper | Art |
| Baron | Hylinn |
| Goon | Deonna |
| Saint | Paul |
| Mayor | Chris |
| Librarian | Wesley |
| Butler | Kira |
| Soldier | Nico |
Night 1:
- Megan sees Chambermaid/Investigator/Grandmother and minions Hylinn/Deonna and Marionette Lyn
- Serene sees Frankie as Marionette and sees bluffs Chambermaid/Investigator/Chef
- Nelson poisons self
- Wesley sees Deonna/Paul as Goon
- Griffin gets 0
- Kira butlers Nico
- Brian picks Paul, Paul sees Brian as Nightwatchman
Day 1:
- Griffin -> Lyn: 5
- Art -> Chris: 3
- No execution
Night 2:
- Art innkeeps Brian/Griffin, drunks Griffin
- Megan picks Griffin, Serene learns this
- Serene picks Paul, Serene dies to Fang Gu, Paul is evil Fang Gu (14 players left)
- Paul learns Marionette and Lunatic
- Griffin gets 0 even though drunk
- Kira butlers Nico
- Art innkeeps Lyn/Paul, drunks Lyn
- Megan picks Kira, Paul learns this
- Paul kills Kira (12 players left)
- Griffin gets 0
- Frankie undertakes Investigator (Marionette)
Day 3:
- Paul -> Nelson: 7
- Nelson -> Megan: 7
- Lyn -> Paul: 0
- Art -> Wesley: 8 (Ghost: Kira)
- Wesley executed, dies (11 players left)
Night 4:
- Art innkeeps Chris/Nico, drunks Chris
- Megan picks Deonna, Deonna drunks Megan, Paul doesn’t learn this
- Paul kills Griffin (10 players left)
- Frankie undertakes Baron (Marionette)
Day 4:
- Nelson -> self: 8
- Lyn -> Chris: 4
- Nelson executed, dies (9 players left)
Night 5:
- Art innkeeps Frankie/Megan, drunks Frankie
- Megan picks Lyn, Paul learns this
- Paul kills Brian (8 players left)
- Frankie undertakes Soldier (drunk)
New Arrivals: Washerwoman → Grandmother, Monk → Innkeeper, Recluse → Goon, Lord of Typhon → Kazali
Game 3 Notes
Game 3
15 players = 9/2/3/1
| Starting Character | Player |
| --- | --- |
| Undertaker | Nelson |
| Chef | Lyn |
| Imp | Megan |
| Nightwatchman | Frankie |
| Empath | Serene |
| Slayer | Brian |
| Spy | Griffin |
| Chambermaid | Art |
| Scarlet Woman | Hylinn |
| Grandmother | Deonna |
| Ravenkeeper | Paul |
| Lunatic (Imp) | Chris |
| Mayor | Wesley |
| Goon | Kira |
| Poisoner | Nico |
Night 1:
- Chris sees minions Megan/Nico/Griffin and sees bluffs Investigator/Soldier/Innkeeper
- Megan sees Investigator/Soldier/Innkeeper
- Nico poisons Wesley
- Lyn gets 0
- Serene gets 0
- Deonna sees Serene as Empath
- Frankie picks Paul, Paul sees Frankie as Nightwatchman
- Art picks Griffin/Brian: 1
Day 1:
- Wesley -> Megan: 12
- Megan -> Wesley: 1
- Megan executed, dies and Hylinn is now Imp (14 players left)
Night 2:
- Nico poisons Wesley
- Chris picks Nico, Hylinn learns this
- Hylinn kills Serene (13 players left) so Deonna dies to Grandmother ability (12 players left)
- Nelson undertakes Imp
- Art picks Kira/Frankie: 0
- Chris picks Wesley, Hylinn learns this
- Hylinn kills Brian (8 players left)
- Art picks Lyn/Paul: 0
Day 4:
- Lyn -> Paul: 4
- Paul -> Wesley: 2 (Ghost: Nico)
- Art -> Hylinn: 3
- Kira -> Lyn: 2
- Paul executed, dies (7 players left)
Night 5:
- Chris picks Kira, Kira drunks Chris, Hylinn does not learn Chris’ pick
- Hylinn kills no one
- Art picks Hylinn/Wesley: 1
Day 5:
- Lyn -> Frankie: 1
- Frankie -> Hylinn: 3
- Kira -> Lyn: 3
- Art -> Chris: 3
- No execution
Night 6:
- Chris picks Kira, Kira drunks Chris, Hylinn does not learn Chris’ pick
- Hylinn kills Wesley, no mayor bounce because evil is losing badly (6 players left)
- Art picks Kira/Lyn: 0
Day 6:
- Art -> Hylinn: 5 (Ghost: Wesley)
- Lyn -> Kira: 1
- Hylinn executed, dies (5 players left, no demon)
Nightwatchman: Everett
Poisoner: Frankie
Lord of Typhon: Deonna
Spy: Hylinn
Scarlet Woman: Kira
Monk: Nelson
Empath: Griffin
Recluse: Chris
Mayor: Wesley
Washerwoman: Nico
Saint: Lyn
Bureaucrat (Good): Megan
Bluffs: Librarian/Undertaker/Soldier
Setup: Original tokens for minions were Slayer (Kira), Ravenkeeper (Hylinn), Butler (Frankie)
Night 1:
- Frankie poisons Everett
- Everett nightwatches Frankie but is poisoned
- Megan triples Lyn
- Nico sees Hylinn/Frankie as Ravenkeeper (Spy)
- Griffin gets 1 (Recluse)
Day 1:
- Lyn -> Chris: 9 (Triple: Lyn)
- Chris executed, dies (10+1 players left)
Night 2:
- Frankie poisons Nelson
- Nelson tries to protect Wesley but is poisoned
- Deonna kills self, Kira is new Lord of Typhon (9+1 players left)
- Griffin gets 0
- Megan triples Frankie